THE 15 BEST Restaurants in Seymour, IN - With Menus, Reviews, Photos - Updated August 2024 (2024)

Customers` Favorites

“Brooklyn Pizza Co. is a popular restaurant known for its delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. They offer a variety of options, including hand-tossed pizzas, chicken bacon ranch, and wings. The restaurant takes pride in cooking everything to order, ensuring freshness and quality. The staff is friendly, and the owner is known for taking care of the community. The cleanliness and parking options are added bonuses.”

Customers` Favorites

“Lola's Modern Kitchen is a must-visit restaurant with delicious food and a great atmosphere. The Deep South and Turkey bacon and Swiss sandwich are highly recommended. The online ordering process is easy, and the staff is friendly and efficient. The menu offers a variety of options, including burgers, nachos, and cheesecake chimichangas. The restaurant is clean and even has free games like Galaga and Mortal Combat. Lola's is a local gem that serves fresh, tasty food and provides a fun dining experience for everyone.”

Customers` Favorites

“Vat & Barrel offers delicious food, including pulled pork nachos, and an impressive selection of local distilleries. The swanky atmosphere and friendly staff make for a great dining experience. The restaurant excels in every category, serving huge and flavorful steaks, great co*cktails, and more, making it a must-visit in Seymour, IN.”

Customers` Favorites

“Schwätzer's German Restaurant is a delightful dining establishment located downtown, offering delicious homemade food at reasonable prices. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, including the knowledgeable front of house manager, contribute to a memorable experience. Notable menu items include brisket and pretzels. With a touch of local history, this restaurant is a must-visit.”

Customers` Favorites

“Azul Tequila in Seymour IN is a gem on the road from Chicago to Nashville. The service is top-notch, with attentive staff and excellent food. They go above and beyond, accommodating dietary restrictions and offering delicious dishes like burritos. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible, with a helpful staff. If you're craving authentic Mexican cuisine, this place is a must-visit.”

Customers` Favorites

“Batar is a charming restaurant nestled among pine trees with a whimsical cafe vibe. The staff is friendly, the food is fresh, and the freshly brewed tea is a must-try. They offer a variety of dishes including sandwiches, soups, desserts, and drinks. The setting is beautiful and tranquil, with a lovely dining room overlooking gardens and woods. The wait staff is polite, and the gift shop offers unique items. Vegetarian options are available on the menu. Visitors can enjoy a relaxing meal and friendly service, making it feel like a mini vacation. It comes highly recommended for a unique and delightful experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“Brewskies Downtown is a restaurant known for its friendly staff and great food. Despite just missing the kitchen cut-off, the staff went out of their way to serve chili dogs to a family passing through. A group from Michigan, in town for a race, enjoyed their experience so much they visited twice. Business travelers also appreciated the restaurant for its good meals and chill atmosphere. Recommended dishes include chili dogs and burgers. The welcoming and accommodating staff make it a place worth visiting.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Fish Stand is a popular spot for seafood lovers. The restaurant serves a variety of fish dishes, including cod, catfish, and pollock. The fish is often lightly breaded, allowing customers to taste its natural flavor. The staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is cozy with quaint decor and impressive stuffed bass displays. The restaurant also offers a special program for those in need, providing free meals to the poor and homeless.”

Customers` Favorites

“Morales Mexican Restaurant serves delicious Mexican food with excellent salsa and chips. Their steak/asada tacos are full of flavor and meaty goodness, while the chorizo tacos are flavorful and not too oily or fatty. The green avocado, jalapeño crema salsa and red crema salsa are also highly praised. The restaurant offers great service, atmosphere, and prices, making it the best place to eat Mexican food in the area.”

Customers` Favorites

“Larrison's Diner is a local eatery that prides itself on knowing its customers and serving fresh, fried food. It's a casual spot where friends can gather and enjoy friendly prices. While the atmosphere may not be elegant, the diner exudes nostalgia. The staff is super friendly, and the food is spectacular. However, parking can be a challenge, especially during busy times, and wheelchair accessibility may be limited due to its street location. Despite these drawbacks, Larrison's Diner is highly recommended for a visit.”

Customers` Favorites

“Reed’s Place: Steak and Chop Shop offers top-quality steaks prepared perfectly. With friendly service, delicious sides, and a great drink selection with live music in the upstairs lounge, it is a must-visit. Try the tomahawk steak or smoked pork chop for a delicious meal. Don't miss out on the homemade peanut butter finger pie for dessert!”

Customers` Favorites

“Rockford Ridge is a hidden gem that exceeds expectations. Despite its unassuming exterior, the restaurant serves exceptional food and provides a welcoming atmosphere. The tenderloin sandwiches, including the Ms. Pig, are a highlight, featuring thick, hand-pounded, and fresh meat. The onion rings, mushrooms, and Big Cheesy sandwich are also popular items. Friendly staff and great shakes complete the experience. This beloved local spot has been a favorite for decades, and its commitment to traditional recipes has earned it a loyal following.”

Customers` Favorites

“Mi Casa Mexican Restaurant offers a solid menu with a range of selections, including a better vegetarian menu than many other Mexican restaurants. While the food is not exceptional, it is good. The restaurant has great service, both fast and friendly. However, the establishment could benefit from a deeper cleaning, including the ceiling vents, and some decorative improvements to enhance the atmosphere.”

Customers` Favorites

“Taco Mix is a restaurant that offers authentic Mexican food, with a highlight on their street tacos and burritos. The meat is marinated to perfection, and the portions are generous. The restaurant has a casual atmosphere, and the staff is bilingual and friendly. They accept both cash and card, and have an ATM inside. The restaurant is suitable for families, as they offer a variety of options on their menu, including corn and flour tacos, and tostadas. The meat and beans have rich flavors, making it a top choice for a meal. The location is convenient for travelers, and it is recommended for anyone looking for a satisfying meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Pines is a family-friendly restaurant with a delicious and fun atmosphere. The buffet offers a variety of dishes, including fantastic fried chicken, fresh carved roast beef and ham, and a great salad bar, though some items like the mashed potatoes may be hit or miss. The decor is consistent with an older establishment, and the restaurant is very wheelchair accessible. The food and service are always exceptional, with friendly and helpful servers.”

Customers` Favorites

“Moxie Coffee Company is a wonderful coffee shop known for its exceptional coffee and friendly service. The staff, including Monte, are personable and attentive, making it a great spot for both work and socializing. The menu offers standouts like smooth espresso, excellent pour-overs, and tasty dishes like avocado toast and breakfast sandwiches. Ideal for families, it features a kid-friendly kitchen play area and nearby grassy plaza. Visitors can enjoy fast Wi-Fi and a variety of seating options. Don't miss their Cuban coffee and lemon blueberry muffins.”

Customers` Favorites

“Best Donut #1 is a restaurant known for its delicious and varied doughnuts, which feature a unique white filling similar to powdered sugar. The team is friendly, and the restaurant is impeccably clean. The doughnuts are fresh and warm, melting in your mouth upon biting into them. The restaurant has a great selection of doughnuts and convenient hours. The owners are praised for their hard work and kindness.”

Customers` Favorites

“Kovener's Korner Ice Cream is a cozy and romantic spot with delicious cookies and cream and strawberry wafers. A family favorite since the 40s, it offers yummy treats like strawberry shortcake and friendly service. Enjoy a cone, cup, shake, or avalanche - a summer staple in Seymour. Fair prices and a must-visit for a good time with friends or a sweet treat with loved ones.”

Customers` Favorites

“On the Rox is a fun place with great drinks and a welcoming atmosphere. The staff, especially Brooke, is quick and skilled at making drinks. The food, like the meat lovers pizza, is delicious and comes in generous portions. The only downside is that it's a smoking bar. Wheelchair accessibility is good with a ramp near the entrance. Overall, a fantastic spot for a good time with awesome people.”

Customers` Favorites

“1852 Cafe is a hidden gem offering a gluten-free menu, featuring delicious treats like frappes, muffins, and biscuits & gravy. The atmosphere is laid-back and kid-friendly, with easy wheelchair accessibility. Friendly staff and phenomenal coffee make it a must-visit spot, with prices comparable to chain cafes.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Seymour Brewing Co. offers a vibrant atmosphere with great staff and owner support for live music. The menu features delectable craft beer, Irish Red and Earache ales, and tasty dishes like pickle pizza and Nashville hot wings. The service and atmosphere are praised, making it a highly recommended spot for visitors.”

Customers` Favorites

“Poplar Street Restaurant is a charming hole-in-the-wall spot with a friendly atmosphere and great food. Their Country Fried Steak is excellent, and their burgers and French fries are also a hit. They offer great deals, like half-price pizza, and serve cold beer to pair with your meal. The staff is exceptionally nice, making it a wonderful spot to return to.”

Customers` Favorites

“Culver's offers a consistently great dining experience, with clean facilities, friendly staff, and delicious hot meals. The restaurant goes above and beyond to meet customers' expectations, providing a positive and satisfying experience, even with the unique drive-thru system. Culver's is highly recommended for those with time to spare.”

Customers` Favorites

Customers` Favorites

“Rails Craft Brew & Eatery is a popular spot that offers a range of delicious dishes. The sweet potato fries are a kid-friendly favorite, while the grilled chicken wrap and nachos with chicken are popular choices among adults. The restaurant also serves grilled chicken, lean meat, and burgers, including the jalapeño popper burger. The staff is known for providing excellent service, with servers like Hayden going above and beyond to ensure a great dining experience. With its tasty food and great service, Rails Craft Brew & Eatery has earned a loyal following among customers.”

Customers` Favorites

“Humble Donut Co. is a charming spot with exceptional customer service. The staff is friendly and helpful, offering flavor recommendations and making mini donuts fresh in front of customers. The donuts are warm, fresh, and delicious, with unique flavors and toppings like strawberries, blueberries, and coconut. Chef Mike's handcrafted treats are a work of art, made with love and care. With samples available, customers can try before they buy, and the freshness and quality are well worth the price.”

Customers` Favorites

“Pizza Palace, Inc. is a popular pizza restaurant located in Seymour, Indiana. According to reviews, the pizza is outstanding, with one customer describing it as "great pizza" and a "pizza snob" praising it as "outstanding." The restaurant also offers delicious submarine sandwiches and breadsticks, with one customer raving about an "incredible submarine" that was "absolutely perfect." The service is commended, with a friendly and attentive server making the dining experience even better. The restaurant is known for its timely delivery and consistent quality, with one customer noting the food is "especially good there" and the delivery person being "super nice." Overall, Pizza Palace, Inc. is a beloved local favorite, offering delicious food and great service.”

Customers` Favorites

“Taqueria La Mejor offers delicious and mouth-watering Mexican cuisine. The restaurant serves a variety of dishes, including enchiladas, chicken soft tacos, and burritos, all of which are hot, fresh, and flavorful. The homemade salsa is a highlight, with one reviewer declaring it the best they've had in the county. The service is impeccable, even when the restaurant is not busy. The prices are affordable, making it a great option for a quick and satisfying meal. Overall, Taqueria La Mejor is a must-visit destination for those craving authentic and tasty Mexican food.”

Customers` Favorites

“Marisqueria El 7 Mares serves fresh and delicious seafood in generous portions. Try their campechana co*cktail, mixed ceviche, and fish tacos. The friendly and attentive staff provide exceptional service. With reasonable prices, this highly recommended restaurant is a great find, where the chef and staff go the extra mile to ensure a wonderful dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“Sunshine Café is a great spot to stop for a quick bite near the interstate. They offer healthy options at an affordable price and prepare food quickly. Serving breakfast all day is a big plus. Menu choices are good, with vegetarian options like the Vegetarian Omelette. Friendly service and a clean environment make it a great place to eat.”

“Frosted is a charming bakery and cafe, adorned with festive decorations and a cozy atmosphere. Their sweet treats are a highlight, with delicious options like oatmeal pie cookies, apple pie cupcakes, and pumpkin spiced lattes. The facility is beautifully designed, accommodating parties and families with a playroom and high chairs. Frosted is also known for its exceptional customer service, going above and beyond to meet customers' needs.”

“Orange Leaf is a fantastic frozen yogurt spot, offering great quality and customer service. A Humble Donuts location inside adds to its appeal, with knowledgeable and friendly staff. The store is very clean and has a fun atmosphere. Visitors can enjoy various flavors of frozen yogurt and toppings or custom mini donuts. A simple cup of brewed coffee is also available.”

Customers` Favorites

“San Marcos Mexican Restaurant serves delicious Mexican food and excellent margaritas. The menu features generous portions, including the massive "monster burrito". The friendly and attentive staff provide fast service in a clean and festive atmosphere. The restaurant is family-friendly with a kids' menu and wheelchair accessible. With plenty of parking, it's a great spot for a enjoyable meal at a reasonable price.”

Customers` Favorites

“Bubba's Place is a nice, decent bar and lunch spot with good food and service. The layout offers a lively side with music and hustle, as well as a quiet and simple side. Visitors passing through found the bartender Mandy sweet and helpful. It's a welcoming spot in the Bible belt with good drinks and a friendly atmosphere. Known for delicious food for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, it's a place where you feel like family. And don't forget, they also serve alcohol!”

“Friendly staff!Delicious shakes!”

Customers` Favorites

“Morales Antojitos Mexicanos offers an authentic Mexican dining experience. The food is consistently praised as "amazing" and "very good" with generous portions and delectable flavors, particularly the pollo asado. The restaurant also features a refreshing ambiance with lively Latin music and an adjacent ice cream shop for dessert.”

Customers` Favorites

“McAlister's Deli is a friendly and helpful establishment. Staff members are courteous and willing to resolve any issues that may arise. The food is delicious, with notable mentions of the French Dip and broccoli and cheddar soup. The restaurant also sells unique items, such as Christmas ornaments, which can be purchased for special occasions. Overall, McAlister's Deli is a great destination for a quick and tasty meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Freddy's Frozen Custard & Steakburgers offers delicious burgers, cheese curds, and onion rings, with some customers praising the great value of their meals. The staff is known for their kindness, attentiveness, and efficient service. However, there have been comments about the small portion of custard served for its price. The tea could be improved, as some found it similar to water.”

Customers` Favorites

“El Nopal Mexican Cuisine is a highly-recommended spot for delicious meals. Their steak quesadilla is a standout, with a generous portion of tender steak, peppers, onions, and cheese, perfectly seasoned. The restaurant is kid-friendly and offers parking right outside. With a top-notch food quality and phenomenal taste, El Nopal is a must-visit for anyone craving great Mexican cuisine.”

Customers` Favorites

“Rally's in Seymour is a popular dining destination for locals and travelers alike. The restaurant is known for its fresh, seasoned fries and tender fried chicken, which many consider the best in town. With a comfortable lobby and convenient parking, it's a great spot to enjoy a meal with family. Customers praise the friendly staff and consistently fast, high-quality service, making it a reliable choice for a satisfying meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Phenomenal service! Friendly staff! We had a tenderloin, zucchini sticks and chicken salad! It was made to order just before they closed and the quality was great! Great experience and would definitely visit again!”

Customers` Favorites

“Tokyo Hibachi & Sushi is a small, quaint restaurant in Seymour that offers an authentic Asian dining experience. The atmosphere is cozy and the customer service is praised, with a friendly and attentive staff. The sushi menu is diverse, and customers enjoy the variety of options, such as the crab and shrimp maki rolls. The bento boxes and other Japanese dishes, like the shrimp tempura, are also well-received, though the quality of the ingredients may not be top-notch.The restaurant is open every day except Mondays, with a break from 2-4 pm. While the overall dining experience is positive, there are a few areas that could use improvement. The take-out service is sometimes unreliable, with the phone going unanswered and the restaurant being closed during regular hours. Additionally, the side salad is described as being just lettuce, with a suggestion to add more vegetables.Despite these minor drawbacks, Tokyo Hibachi & Sushi is a welcome addition to the Seymour dining scene, offering authentic Japanese cuisine in a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. Customers leave feeling full and satisfied, though their wallets may be a bit lighter due to the slightly higher prices.”

Customers` Favorites

“The Arby's restaurant in Seymour, Indiana is a popular choice among locals and visitors alike. The Classic Roast Beef sandwich and crinkly fries are praised for their outstanding taste and quality. The roast beef is juicy and flavorful, while the fries are always fresh and delicious. The staff is highly commended for their exceptional service, professionalism, and friendly demeanor. The restaurant is well-managed, with the shift manager and general manager setting a positive example for the team. Customers appreciate the clean restrooms and the overall pleasant dining experience. Arby's is seen as a reliable and rewarding choice, often used as an incentive for hard work.”

Customers` Favorites

“Chili's Grill & Bar offers good food that arrives quickly. The restaurant is conveniently located near local accommodations and amenities. Servers, such as Jason and Ashley, provide attentive and friendly service, even in busy situations. Jason went above and beyond to ensure a pleasant dining experience, while Ashley consistently demonstrated great attitude and refills on drinks. The restaurant's pick 2 items and get a drink deal is a popular option, and Seymour American-style food is a highlight.”

Customers` Favorites

“Buffet China is a restaurant known for its hot and fresh buffet. The waitstaff are attentive, ensuring drinks are refilled and tables are cleaned. While the cost has increased over the years, the food, particularly the chicken entrées, are generally regarded as good. However, some may find the options limited and the absence of the Mongolian grill noticeable. It is noted that the restaurant could benefit from daily variety in their entrée options. Despite a previous negative experience involving food poisoning, some customers have fond memories and continue to visit the establishment. The cleanliness of the aquarium in the front could also be improved.”

Customers` Favorites

“Papa Johns Pizza offers a varied pizza menu, with options to customize orders. The restaurant provides responsive customer service, addressing any issues promptly. Customers generally enjoy the taste of the pizzas, though the quality of preparation can vary. Overall, Papa Johns Pizza offers a satisfactory dining experience.”

Customers` Favorites

“ordered a 32 piece and were not disappointed! got Nashville hot and santa fe. Nashville wasn't very hot but still tasty. wings were great size and cooked perfectly. so juicy. fries also good. just needed a tad more seasoning. 8 out of 10 will order again!”

Customers` Favorites

“White Castle offers a great experience with tasty sliders and sides like onion chips and fries. The staff is polite, informative, and creates a clean environment. Although the drive-thru service can be slow due to the busy nature of the restaurant, the hot and delicious food makes up for it. Whether you're craving a crave case or a quick meal, White Castle's friendly service and great food will leave you satisfied.”

Customers` Favorites

“Charleys Cheesesteaks offers a great experience with hot, fresh, and delicious food. The staff is friendly, and the chicken teriyaki sandwich and cajun fries are heavenly. The restaurant is wheelchair accessible and conveniently located near accessible parking at a BP gas station. It's a must-visit spot for a satisfying meal.”

Customers` Favorites

“Best Chinese food in Seymour! Always friendly, always fresh and delicious! My favorite Chinese restaurant.”

Customers` Favorites

“Subway in Seymour is a popular choice for fresh sandwiches, with a drive-thru option available. Customers praise the attentive staff who get the orders right the first time. Despite a slightly higher price point, the quality of the food exceeds expectations, making it worth the visit. The location stands out for its consistently fresh and soft bread, unlike other nearby Subway branches. The friendly service and overall dining experience make it a top choice for sandwich lovers in the area.”

“Decent store, clean, restrooms were clean. I spoke to 4 different associates and all 4 were pleasant and helpful. However, one young associate walked past me in the aisle muttering "I hate this job, I hate this job..." Also, I do not like the new carts with the high handles, very awkward and uncomfortable.”